Body part : Legs
Insurance: $2 million
The newest judge on America's Got Talent had her legs insured for $2 million in 2004, but who knew that they were unevenly valued? "Basically, I was in London, and I had to go to this place where they check out your legs. They would look at them and I had one scar here from when I fell on a glass, so this [left leg] isn't as pricey as this [right] one," she said.